It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
a reply to: Ghost147
So basically the first and last sentences of your reply is the single tenant for Atheism?
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
a reply to: Ghost147
So a lack of belief in a god is not a description of atheistic view?
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
Well there is a description so is must be the base for being an Atheist. Having a base discrition for being an Atheist is a tenant in and of itself.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
If there is a base then you must in some way defend that base description.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
Does an Atheist do anything to promote the base description to others?
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
anyone can choose to believe or not believe in anything that is not inherently make a person an Atheist.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
So what makes an Atheist and Atheist.
Tenent was the common spelling in the 1600s for tenet, which was defined as a belief or principle. www.yourdictionary.com...
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
a reply to: Ghost147
What makes a person an Atheist is their assertation that they lack faith in a god. that is the principle of Atheism.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
a reply to: Ghost147
here is the simple dictionary I used in my understanding of Tenent.Tenent was the common spelling in the 1600s for tenet, which was defined as a belief or principle. www.yourdictionary.com...
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
a reply to: Ghost147
So the principle of atheism that makes a person an Atheist is the lack of belief of a god.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
a reply to: Ghost147
So why is it you lack faith in a god?
However, If you're just asking out of personal curiosity. I lack a belief in any and all gods because there isn't any evidence to even suggest one exists, and all of our observations we've made so far relate to a natural origin and natural functioning for everything. There is simply no reason or need for a god to exist at all.
I have no belief. I don't have any proof for their being a god and I don't have any proof of their not being a god. I'll wait and see when there's either proof or I'm dead, whichever comes quicker.
There is simply no reason or need for a god to exist at all.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
After reading your reply above I remember Terry, who claimed to be an agnostic say the same thing
The only difference is the wording.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
You added a qualifying statement which interests me. do all Atheist believe this, There is simply no reason or need for a god to exist at all.
originally posted by: ChesterJohn
Why do you believe there is no reason or need for a god to exist?
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
I would say I'm an agnostic.
I don't refuse there being a god because I can't prove it.
I don't say there is a god because I can't prove it.
There is no evidence there is or is not a god. I'll wait and see when I die
originally posted by: Ghost147
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
I would say I'm an agnostic.
I don't refuse there being a god because I can't prove it.
I don't say there is a god because I can't prove it.
There is no evidence there is or is not a god. I'll wait and see when I die
That's soft atheism.
If you believe we cannot know if God exists (until we die) then that would be agnosticism
originally posted by: TerryDon79
originally posted by: Ghost147
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
I would say I'm an agnostic.
I don't refuse there being a god because I can't prove it.
I don't say there is a god because I can't prove it.
There is no evidence there is or is not a god. I'll wait and see when I die
That's soft atheism.
If you believe we cannot know if God exists (until we die) then that would be agnosticism
So I'm both an agnostic and an atheist?
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
We don't have evidence either way, never said we would find proof. I already said I'd find out when I die.
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
So by that and your definitions that would make me an agnostic atheist, no?
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
I just thought. Is it because of the bit I said if it came down it would have to prove it was god? (I said that earlier)
originally posted by: Ghost147
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
I just thought. Is it because of the bit I said if it came down it would have to prove it was god? (I said that earlier)
I don't recall you saying that. I was just commenting on the quote that Chester posted of your response
originally posted by: TerryDon79
originally posted by: Ghost147
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
I just thought. Is it because of the bit I said if it came down it would have to prove it was god? (I said that earlier)
I don't recall you saying that. I was just commenting on the quote that Chester posted of your response
Ah ok. I'm sure I said it in here somewhere, might have been a different thread.
My stance is all based on evidence. We don't have any for either side of the argument. I can't possibly know if there is or isn't until I die or it comes down and proves it.
I was brought up Church of England (Christian), Christian primary school, church on Sunday, Sunday school, but never had a belief in god because there has never been any proof for me.
originally posted by: Ghost147
originally posted by: TerryDon79
originally posted by: Ghost147
originally posted by: TerryDon79
a reply to: Ghost147
I just thought. Is it because of the bit I said if it came down it would have to prove it was god? (I said that earlier)
I don't recall you saying that. I was just commenting on the quote that Chester posted of your response
Ah ok. I'm sure I said it in here somewhere, might have been a different thread.
My stance is all based on evidence. We don't have any for either side of the argument. I can't possibly know if there is or isn't until I die or it comes down and proves it.
I was brought up Church of England (Christian), Christian primary school, church on Sunday, Sunday school, but never had a belief in god because there has never been any proof for me.
But you do believe that a god could be proven in some way, sometime in the future, but before you die?