It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
CONCLUSION
It is interesting to note that these Messianic prophecies foretell the nations' subjugation to Israel. If Jesus was really the Messiah and the Jews persecuted and killed him, why is G-d going to reward them so greatly? Partly for not yielding to centuries of Christian persecution.
Moreover, when looking back at all of these prophecies, we can clearly see Jesus is not the Messiah. Jesus fell short of fulfilling any of the major messianic prophecies; he was never anointed as King, he never ruled Israel, and the world was certainly not perfected in his time. In addition, he was not preceded by the return of the prophet Elijah. To suggest Jesus is the Jewish Messiah is, in effect, saying that G-d was lying to the Jewish people when he promised a Messiah from the house of David who would fulfill all of the prophecies.
I surmised correctly, therefore I put no words in your mouth. Regards Josephus’ works then, you readily submit that Christians tampered with his words, and therefore you would rather cast a blind eye to all such works. Yet, you have not explained what purpose he would have to fabricate the information on the temple. So another question comes your way:
1)is it not also true that the authoritative information on all aspect of the temple during the 1st century ACE, comes to us from Josephus?
Therefore
But I said that Josephus is the ONLY one to mention the walls being leveled.
this account of same cannot be dismissed. Correct?
They not only doctored same, they rewrote the history of their Egyptian heritage into a new set of myths, and the Torah is nothing but the retelling of the same Egyptian myths over and over.
Oh? And the two books were removed because?
I understand your position, choose what suits your purpose and discard what does not. If Ezekiel or for that matter any book is questionable in any part, then it should all be tossed. For if the author was deceitful in one area, he was likely deceitful in others.
I have provided you with a timeline, you have provided nothing but denial. Show me exactly to what his prophecy referred and substantiate your denial.
Mention of the Ark of the Testimony ceased before the looting of the temple by Neuchadnezzar, in fact, it ceased to be spoken about during Hezekiah’s reign. Consequently, Zerubbabel’s temple also lacked the ark, did it not?
I asked you to provide the requirement for three exiles before the third temple is rebuilt. A depiction as to which exiles happened when does not answer the question.
Further, you cannot be in Roman exile, since the Jews never acquired the exact piece of real estate promised to Abraham, in which case by technicality they are still in the first exile.
The request to provide information relative to Ezekiel’s prophecy or stating the temple will be destroyed twice before its final rebuild has not been provided. Further, given that you state;
We are STILL in the Roman exile.
this next does not make sense;
Putting this into perspective with "Herod's Temple" or "Onias Temple" there was NO exile..
since, Israel was under Roman siege at the time of Herod.
You are an adult debating on a message board, as am I, therefore, and speaking from my perspective only, while it is often I find my opponent is of a tender age, it serves no purpose to be engaging them in debate if they cannot even understand grade 10 language. What good does it do to be providing definitions of your words, just so they might begin to understand the meaning of a sentence?
Now I wish to draw you back to context and note some outstanding requests:
2) The mention of a prophesied 3rd temple.
3) Why would you expect the Tanakh to mention Herod?
4) Zerubbabel’s was a new temple because of a new foundation, according to you, why then was Herod’s not?
5) Your response to their being two schools of thought as to both Zeruabbabel’s and Herod’s temple being the second, and why, the other is not considered.
Relative to the rest of your posts, and considering the unanswered above as well as the issues with your argument as outlined, I give you the following analysis;
When one is called up into heaven, one should expect that being in the firmament, EWNS directions either do not apply or cannot be discernible, yet Ezekiel, seemed to be firmly grounded by compass directions.
Ezekiel is the prophet upon whom Jews place all reliance for the rebuilding of the temple,
yet, God while most willing to speak with him refuses through Ezekiel himself to speak with the elders, ch. 20;
Originally posted by Somewhereinbetween
They not only doctored same, they rewrote the history of their Egyptian heritage into a new set of myths, and the Torah is nothing but the retelling of the same Egyptian myths over and over.
Originally posted by Shonet1430
Do you think that we are not taught that there are many stories that are not unique to us? Is this like some huge shocker? I'm a Jew and I know about it. I had to learn it somewhere. Does it change anything for me? Not at all. My faith is bound to people and events. It's bound by me and my personal relationship to G-d.
Originally posted by Somewhereinbetween
I understand your position, choose what suits your purpose and discard what does not. If Ezekiel or for that matter any book is questionable in any part, then it should all be tossed. For if the author was deceitful in one area, he was likely deceitful in others.
Originally posted by Shonet1430
I didn't question his book. I rejected your interpretation of his book.
Originally posted by Shonet1430
But we as Jews are still in exile (hence the ingathering of Jews when the moshaich arrives) and there has not been that ingathering yet and there is no moshaich to lay the cornerstone.
Originally posted by Somewhereinbetween
Further, you cannot be in Roman exile, since the Jews never acquired the exact piece of real estate promised to Abraham, in which case by technicality they are still in the first exile.
Originally posted by Shonet1430
Now this makes no sense.
Originally posted by Shonet1430
The messiah will lay the cornerstone for the Temple.
Originally posted by djohnsto77
Would the Ark of the Covenant need to be recovered to truly complete the temple and fulfill prophesy?
Originally posted by banjo_guru
They do not really need anything but the altar to get things moving.
Myth or no myth, this is a valid point, Shonet. There is a definite connection.
If you know about the Egyptian connection to Israel, Shonet, why then do you close your mind to possiblities of an now Egyptian-owned homeland?
Shouldn't this change something for you? I mean, we're talking about physical territory, not ambiguous faith in G-d, right?
Well what mountain is he talking about in ch43? Mt. Zion? Mt. Moriah? Is not it a little silly to call a mild incline a mountain?
What cornerstone? The one mentioned in Zechariah? Could not a cornerstone lay on top of a pyramid?
Actually, it makes a whole lotta sense.
What about Zerrubabbel? (Zech. 4:7) And are you not merely assuming that the cornerstone goes on the Temple?
Originally posted by Shonet1430
G-d promised certain land and did not say, "Hey, I'm going to change things up for you and decide to plant you somewhere else."
Israel is it.
G-d told us in Isaiah that he didn't keep anything from us and that he did not speak to us from a dark place where we couldn't see him.
Everything he needed for us to know, he told us. So to me, as a Jew, there are no other options.
Well it would be where the others were built, the land purchased by David, and shown throughout the Tanakh....Moriah.
Moriah fits the description of a mountain as it only has to be about 600 meters to include two different climate zones. Moriah is 777 meters northeast of the mount and the mount is 740ish.
Originally posted by Dallas
Hi There..
Must disagree with you there. Ethiopia and the Ark's whereabouts were investigated. Mr Burgess back in I believe 1997.
Then from there after seeing the Knights Templar insignia on the very-close by Chapel he followed it (more than Ark) back to Scotland, at Roslyn.
Where after speaking with some very 'powerful' yet silent-named present day Templars would only say that three of the Arks were burried underneath the Roslyn Chapel.
Dallas
The temple will not be built until after the abomination, which is yet to come.
When he comes, the city will be submerged in water from the breaking of the High Answan Dam. This is the flood spoken of in Dan 9 and Rev 12. So the walls(sides of Zion) and street(causeway) are elements along with the altar that will be set up before the abomination.
And you shall know and understand that from the emergence of the word to restore and to rebuild Jerusalem until the anointed king [shall be] seven weeks, and [in] sixty-two weeks it will return and be built street and moat, but in troubled times.
And after the sixty-two weeks, the anointed one will be cut off, and he will be no more, and the people of the coming monarch will destroy the city and the Sanctuary, and his end will come about by inundation, and until the end of the war, it will be cut off into desolation.
And he will strengthen a covenant for the princes for one week, and half the week he will abolish sacrifice and meal- offering, and on high, among abominations, will be the dumb one, and until destruction and extermination befall the dumb one.
This is all that is required for animal sacrifice.
The antichrist will even build his own palace right at the base of Mt. Zion on the east side, between the 2 pools(seas). Now THAT’S audacious!
Originally posted by Shonet1430
There is an "abomination" sitting there now. The Maccabean revolt was thanks to an abomination.
Fah, here we go again. Daniel 9 is a retelling of Jeremiah 25. Daniel prays for understanding and his interpretation comes in verses 24-27.
Let's look at bits of those verses. We have an anointed leader, anointed one and a prince. Who are they? Let's see.
Hmm the word return and rebuild Jerusalem. That is Cyrus giving the word.
Who was killed? The anointed one.
Who is the anointed one? The priest Onias III.
Where is there a mention of a literal flood?
Antiochus ring a bell? He ceased sacrifices and offering and then what happened? A statue of Zeus was put on the altar and Jews were forced to pray. A pig one of the most unclean animals were sacrificed on the altar.
The antichrist will even build his own palace right at the base of Mt. Zion on the east side, between the 2 pools(seas). Now THAT’S audacious!
That's fairytale.
Is it not pheasable that it was not G-d who changed things up, but instead was the forgetfulness of the Jewish people due to generations of exile?
Is it not also possible that the land mentioned in the Tanakh is indeed the land that we now refer to as Egypt?
Could you Jews have "forgotten your restingplace?"
Remember, if you have not place Jerusalem as your chief joy, then let the your tongue cleave to the roof of your mouth, no?
Ch45:15 "You're a G-d that hides yourself" (sjc version)
Ch 19:19 "There's gonna be an altar in the midst of the land of 'Egypt'(sjcv)
Ch 28 They err in vision the priest and prophet both. They're spiritually drunk.(sjcv)
ps 18:11 "his pavilion round about him are dark waters" (sjcv)
True, but maybe you weren't listening close enough?
You mean that filthy piece of Palestinian property that is to become a perpetual waste? The land purchased by David is the land we now call Giza.
There is no evidence, despite what any sensationalistic archaeolgist tells you.
David's Jerusalem: Fiction or Reality?
No. My G-d is everywhere.
O Israel, how long will you have forgotten where your God will reign?
You did the ol' pick and choose as shown above in full context. We are to cleave to G-d. That's in the Torah and the Torah is what contains our laws to abide by.
Say to yourself, "If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget her cunning, let my tongue stick to the roof of my mouth."
I will feel no shame as I follow the word. I do not have ignorance or blindness either. But I understand that Jews returning is part of the end times prophecy as we killed Jesus and now we're holding up his return...hence some churches taking up airfare money to usher us off.
Behold, you will come from the north country back to the land you were promised. You will come from all the ends of the earth. You will remember the place of your rest. You will be utterly ashamed of your ignorance and blindness.
We will come back and be given the land promised during the messianic era.
He will again bring you into the land he has promised you. With the bands of love will he draw you back. The seed of your fathers will be brought back. Your forefathers' hearts will be toward you, and your hearts will be toward your forefathers'.
I had forgotten thanks to being raised a Christian. Better yet, I didn't know and my family had forgotten. I now know.
You have forgotten, but the LORD will never forget you.
Again, where does it say that the land will be perpetually desolate?
You will be like them who dream. Your mouths will be filled with laughter, your tongues with singing, as he turns again your captivity back toward the streams in the south. Can a woman forget her sucking child? Can a maid forget her ornaments, her attire? He will bring his children back to his holy mountain. Stop forsaking this land, stop being stiffnecked. Stop refusing to return. The land which you think is Israel is a cursed land. It will be perpetually desolate. Come out of it, my people. Come all, with weeping and remorse. Rend your hearts. Be contrite. Be sober and come to the holy land. Cast ye up, cast ye up, prepare the way, take up the stumblingblock out of the way of my people!
hmm, then why does it say that G-d will magnify Zion as the mountain he chooses to dwell in? Why does it say that G-d's servants will take pleasure in Zion's stones? Where are Zion's stones, anyway? Why is Zion mentioned and honored ALL throughout Isaiah? Where is Moriah in Isaiah? (It aint there, Aimie) What is Zion to you? Why does he call it the perfection of beauty?
Is this? the perfection of beauty?
How 'bout this...
Could not this be the Moriahvan temple?
Why does Josephus say Zion is lower? How can this be? Unless of course Zion has been mislabeled, and sits in the lower part of Jerusalem(Giza)
In your scriptures it is magnified and it will be established forever. not Moriah. Moriah is history. There will be no future temple on Moriah.
Moriah temple burned down long ago and G-d will never rebuild it there, besides you do not even know where Moriah is located.
Is it not also convenient that there is a tributary of the "Nile" which is exactly 4,000 cubits to the east of "The Great Pyramid"?(ez. 47) Could not this "pyramid" be Mt. Zion?
Could not corner stone = head of the corner?
Not "the" abomination.
So we now have an end of sins and are experiencing everlasting righteousness. Gee, I thought it would be less painful than this.
I could tell you but would you believe me?
Who will be killed? The anointed one.
Who is the anointed one? Well let's just say he has a set of horns.
Where is there mention of Moriah being exalted?
Shadows my dear, shadows.
Someday you're prince will come, someday you're prince will come.
What feminine person is Isaiah talking about when the L-rd says sons of strangers will rebuild her walls in ch60?
Who will arise and shine? Mt Moriah? or Mt. Zion?
Is it not convenient that you have ignored my position that you do not even know where you're holy city is located? Evidence is on my side. Why do you choose to be stiffnecked about this. You say you don't want to be in the desert, but is it not true that it is prophesied that there will be streams in the desert and it shall blossom like a rose and be as the gareden of Eden?
The self-fullfilled prophesies you think were already fulfilled are I say VEHEMENTLY false fulfillments.
What is keeping you back from you're true homeland. O Jerusalem, how I would like to gather you as a mother hen gathers her chicks. Why would you refuse to hear from your G-d?
Behold, you're house, you're city, you're country is left unto you desolate, it lies in ruins to this day, you shall not see me 'til you say blessed is he who comes in the name of the L-ord.
Why did Jesus condemn the cities of Chorazin! and Bethsaida!
Why did he condemn the fig tree?
Why did he condemn that filthy, abominable "temple" by saying no stone shall be left unturned?
Why did he say he was sent to the lost sheep of Israel?
Why did Jeremiah say that you people have allowed your shepherds to cause you to go astray and go from mountain to hill and FORGRT YOUR RESTINGPLACE?
Why did Ezra admit that his people were still bondmen even when they were rebuilding the temple? Does not this admit exile?
Why did John compare the city that my L-ord was crucifed in to Sodom and Egypt?
If you can't answer these questions correctly, then I ask someone else, somewhere else. Whether you refuse or accept my doctrine, it shall be established.
The stone that you reject WILL become the head of the corner.
You watch and see.
But ye are they that forsake the L-RD, that forget my holy mountain.
Originally posted by Shonet1430
...that's for us Jews
Moriah is a part of a city that is a part of Zion.
I'm married to my prince. He's not my moshiach.
It's not a freaking mountain.
I do know where it is as there is plenty of evidence to show where it is including that of Josephus. It's nice to see your anti-semitic side come out. Also I haven't said I don't want to be in the desert. I can suggest for you this. Read the Tanakh. Get out a map. Read even Josephus and I'm not a big proponent of his.
NOTHING has been fulfilled messianically speaking. Every generation, a person who has the potential to be our moshiach is born. One day, it will happen.
Who is refusing to hear?I refuse to hear things that you say as I've now drawn certain conclusions about you.
Behold, you're house, you're city, you're country is left unto you desolate, it lies in ruins to this day, you shall not see me 'til you say blessed is he who comes in the name of the L-ord.
New Testament junk. Nice. What does the Tanakh have to say?
Why did Jesus condemn the cities of Chorazin! and Bethsaida!
Why did he condemn the fig tree?
Jesus has NOTHING to do with me so I could care less what he did or when he did it.
Why did he condemn that filthy, abominable "temple" by saying no stone shall be left unturned?
Because he was ticked off that they would let him play his games.
Why did he say he was sent to the lost sheep of Israel?
Who cares?
Why did Jeremiah say that you people have allowed your shepherds to cause you to go astray and go from mountain to hill and FORGRT YOUR RESTINGPLACE?
That's it. You're illiterate. Look it up. I don't mean it as in stupid for the record. Verse 4...."In those days and at that time--declares the L-rd" hmmmmm is that past tense? Yes it is! Verse 6 "My people were lost sheep." Is that also past tense? By golly! I think it is! As a matter of fact! I know it is!
Why did Ezra admit that his people were still bondmen even when they were rebuilding the temple? Does not this admit exile?
Chapter 9 is about intermarriage. Did you miss that part where "holy seed has become intermingled with the peoples of the land?" I guess so since you're a pick and choose kind of guy. Ezra was freaking out. The prayer in verses 6 and 7 is Daniel's prayer and then he goes on to say that they had been granted a short reprieve. You can see through his pleas that Ezra felt certain that the Jews were headed back to being punished. "Will You not rage against us till we are destroyed without remnant or survivor?"
If you can't answer these questions correctly, then I ask someone else, somewhere else. Whether you refuse or accept my doctrine, it shall be established.
Your doctrine? Your doctrine has no bearing on me as it's against G-d's wishes for me. See he warned us about crazies in Deuteronomy 13. He also told us in Deuteronomy that we are to protect ourselves.
if G-d wanted us to know about you then he would have said, "Children, listen up. I'm sending this fellow named Steve who is going to lead you back to where you belong because only he knows the truth out of all of the other billions and billions of people who have lived in this world."
We Jews ARE your cornerstone.
I'm one of the chosen. I'm sorry that bothers you so. I didn't ask to be born a Jew. But I'm certainly glad that G-d found favor on me!
Originally posted by Shonet1430
and the southern border shall be from the edge of the Sea of Salt [the Dead Sea] to the east.
So what exactly is the point? If both the right hand and the tongue are paralyzed, then one can't play the lyre and sing. So to answer your question, no. You shall follow the L-rd, your G-d, fear Him, keep His commandments, heed His voice, worship Him, and cleave to Him. Yes.
Ch45:15 "You're a G-d that hides yourself" (sjc version)
Notice in verse 14, "Thus said the L-rd." G-d is talking to Cyrus as G-d worked through him. Verse 19, "Not in secret did I speak, in a place of a land of darkness."
Ch 19:19 "There's gonna be an altar in the midst of the land of 'Egypt'(sjcv)
This is among one of so I don't know a bajillion things that he also told us and not from a dark place. But that altar is not for the Jewish people. This entire chapter is about what G-d does to Egypt to make them realize that he is the one and only. The purpose of the altar and pillar in verse 19 is explained in verse 20...And it shall be for a sign and for a witness.
ps 18:11 "his pavilion round about him are dark waters" (sjcv)
This is David's description and it actually says thick darkness under his feet, not waters. Also, this is verse 10.
Is to become perpetual waste? Where did G-d say that in the Tanakh?
My G-d is everywhere.
This is perfection of beauty.
Or this. The Torah.
No because this is where the Temple was.
Maybe because Josephus was speaking of the mountain and not Israel in general which is 5 feet lower. Think outside of the box.
So since you know that it burned, obviously you also know where Moriah is.
Originally posted by CyrusTheShepherd
Is it not pheasable that it was not G-d who changed things up, but instead was the forgetfulness of the Jewish people due to generations of exile?
My Father's house shall be called a house of prayer, but you have made it a 'den of thieves.
Originally posted by dbates
Let's see, Moses led Israel's children OUT of Egypt. They wondered through the wilderness, and Crossed the Jordan River to conquer Jericho. Sounds to me like the same place modern day Israel is located.
Are you saying that Jesus was misguided when he drove the money changers out of the Temple? He acknowledged that it was God's house.
My Father's house shall be called a house of prayer, but you have made it a 'den of thieves.
This is the same Temple that the Romans destroyed, the same Temple that Jesus pointed to and said that "Not one stone shall be left on another." He wasn't in Egypt when all this happened.
Jerusalem has been located in the same place for thousands of years and the Temple has always been located in Jerusalem.
My dear, would I not gather your favour by saying you are of the synogogue of Satan, and say that you say you are a Jew but are not?
I didn't think so.
suuuuuure!
You mean your husband is a leader of Israel? or is he a man of fierce countenace who disregards women?
I assume I struck a nerve?
No, I'm pro-semetic. Actually my closest allie is the most G-d fearing Jew in this earth. His name is Israel. He lives in southern Wisconsin. I would like you to meet him. He is a very special young man. If you don't know where that is, get out a map.
Where is the evidence that you blatantly label a trash heap a holy city?
I did not suggest messianically speaking. Your ignorant people claim that in 1948 many of the prophesies in Isaiah had been fullfilled. Mr. Truman actually audaciously declared that he was the latter-day Cyrus. So you planted vineyards and cultivated a barren land. Note I say "a" barren land. Not "the holy land"
I think you just answered your question. So, at least toward me, you are stiffnecked, obstinate, rebellious, backsliding heifer, etc.
Now you must be a little more objective, Aime. For if it is G-d who sent me to converse with you, well, quite frankly, you're in a pickle.
I'm a little too lazy to type "desolate" in my bible search engine.....
You do it, kay? But look in Jeremiah and Isaiah for starters.
Jesus has everything to do with you. You just don't know it.
Why was the curse fulfilled?
HE cares.
If this is past tense, then why do your people need to remember where Zion is?(verse5) Why do they need to ASK where Zion is. How could they forget in 70 years?
Are your people that stupid?
EVEN THO' WE'RE STILL IN BONDAGE TO CYRUS."
HE TOLD YOU TO KILL ME!!!! (VERSE 9)
Remember, if you do not kill me, you are breaking your law, and G-d's heart.
G-d will not speak to you directly because you're people refused to hear him back in the desert. He even said he would not. He uses messengers.
You are not even Jewish.
Yes, he found favour on you by allowing me to show you the way. What bothers me is what bothers him. You're people's resistance.