Member of Knesset calls for internment camps for Families of Palestinian attackers

Moti Yogev, jewish Home MK, proposed incarcerating family members of Palestinian in internment camps and feeding them rations of just bread and water.

He said also "there are other means of deterrence such as banishing families of murderers to the Judean Desert — something that’s possible by law — and the creation of a type of Holot [Detention Facility] run by the Military Police"
source

How can someone think in punishing innocent people just because one member of the family get's nut's? Brothers, sisters, father and mother.. even grandfather and grandmother goes to the concetration camp..

One more disgusting idea to add to the list of collective punishment incitements / actions from Israeli leaders.


Going public with is kind of ideas, all the time, should raise red flag's around the media outlets and leaders of the world. Instead, the "major opinion makers", forget the need of freedom of the Palestinian people, during this "eternal peace process", and proclaim always in favor of Israel, because of the "also eternal" "terrorist's" who were living their lives, before they got occupied.

Yes, the world fails to remember this provocations and ongoing punishment to the besieged people surviving overthere.

It is an annoying sense of deafness that makes anyone wonder why the world stand in this silence!? I can't understand.

Some pictures just to remember / locate what a internment camps means.



nowdays at Israel... (internment camps already(?))



History repeating itself, but this time, victims become the criminals.

a reply to: voyger2

History repeating itself, but this time, victims become the criminals.

As with the Nazi's, kids in Israel seem to be getting educated with the belief that they are better than others, which obviously is always going to cause problems.

Additionally, while they're pillaging & killing unarmed Palestinians, that notion will remain until they actually come up against a proper army, which may provide the reality check needed (the Nazi's even said the seem thing when the first encountered the Russians in combat during WW2).

OK, you quote a few loon MKs, comparable to Israel's Rush Limbaughs or Anne Coulters.
Yet you make no mention of Joint List . You know those israeli MKs whoa re

The Joint List (Hebrew: הרשימה המשותפת‎, HaReshima HaMeshutefet; Arabic: القائمة المشتركة‎, al-Qa'imah al-Mushtarakah) is a political alliance of four Arab-dominated parties in Israel—Hadash, the United Arab List, Balad, and Ta'al.[3]They are the third largest faction in the 20th Knesset.

Politics and ideology[edit]
The list is ideologically diverse and includes communists, socialists, feminists, Islamists, and Palestinian nationalists.[11][12][6] After having united parties with various political agendas, Odeh met with Jewish Hadash activists, including former Knesset speaker Avraham Burg, in an attempt to allay concerns that the new alliance would dilute the party's principles, such as gender equality.[13]

a reply to: voyger2

This is a fairly logical and pragmatic approach that would be more likely to affect change than to simply kill someone who is already willing to be martyred for his or her beliefs. The logic is that you may not care what happens to you, but you do care about your family. It is ironic that someone Jewish would suggest 'camps' as an alternative, but it would probably be effective strategy for deterring the negative behavior.

a reply to: Metallicus

The problem with the «fairly logical and pragmatic approach» is the law. There are multiple laws and moral issues that would be violated (but who cares..right?).

No one can be blamed or punished by actions perpetrated by another.

And, more ever, by:
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Article 5.
No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.

Article 9.
«No one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile.»

The above law has created after ww2 to prevent other "kinds of holocausts" / genocides!

originally posted by: voyger2
a reply to: Metallicus

The problem with the «fairly logical and pragmatic approach» is the law. There are multiple laws and moral issues that would be violated (but who cares..right?).

No one can be blamed or punished by actions perpetrated by another.

And, more ever, by:
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Article 5.
No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.

Article 9.
«No one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile.»

The above law has created after ww2 to prevent other "kinds of holocausts" / genocides!

I don't recall ever signing on to any 'Universal Declaration of Human Rights' nor do I recognize international treaties or laws, however, I was speaking only that the strategy proposed was sound for achieving the given purpose. I didn't speak to the 'moral' or legal issues as I don't really care to comment on them.

All I can say is, ...Learn from your enemies. Because your enemies will not be as gental the second time around... I love it when OP'sters sit in thier safe zone and want to armchair general/politicize Israeli because they're so "civilized"/PC that, they're ignorant. Haven't you learned? Fear is a positive and a negative motivator? What's the real point of your post? Hate Jews, do ya?

a reply to: Metallicus

Don't worry you will cry for the law and justice one day... it's called karma

a reply to: murphy22

I don't hate anyone. I hate unjustice. But don't worry, truth always come to the top .

Meanwhile:
Spanish court issues arrest warrant for Israeli PM Netanyahu

A Spanish court has found Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and six other senior officials guilty of crimes against humanity for their role in the 2010 raid on Gaza-bound aid ship, Mavi Marmara.

The Madrid-based Supreme Court has ordered arrest of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, ex-foreign minister Avigdor Lieberman, ex-defense minister Ehud Barak, then-deputy PMs Moshe Ya'alon and Eli Yishai, and then-state minister Benny Begin. Israel's ex-Navy Commander Eliezer Marom is among the co-defendants found guilty by the Spanish judge.

a reply to: voyger2

A Spanish court? Oh lord! Say it ain't so! Even if it was a "UN" court. I'd believe they're a little outside thier jurisdiction. Lol! Don't you have any real problems in your own country? I never worry about truth. Truth always, will win. So, in effect? Spain declared war, on an "elected" leader of a sovereign nation, through it's "court"? Don't get to wrapped around the folks in black robes...they say a lot of things. Yawwwn!

originally posted by: voyger2
a reply to: Metallicus

The problem with the «fairly logical and pragmatic approach» is the law. There are multiple laws and moral issues that would be violated (but who cares..right?).

No one can be blamed or punished by actions perpetrated by another.

And, more ever, by:
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Article 5.
No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.

Article 9.
«No one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile.»

The above law has created after ww2 to prevent other "kinds of holocausts" / genocides!

Wait a few days or a week. post another anti israeli thread. Once again that Geneva convsntion dont apply due to palestine was not even a legit government or a country at all. they are JORDANIANS and EGYPTIANS and SYRIANS who are not allowwed back in their own countries due to their past relatives/family tring to over throw their g governments.

(Oh ands th e"universal declaration of human rights" if not signed off on by the country in question is legally not bound by it. Its liek the ICC that way.

a reply to: yuppa
try not make this a circus... The Universal Declaration of Human Rights aplies to all humans of this planet. But for the zionist bashers, such as defense minister and others, like you, palestinians are "beasts".. again karma it will kick you in the back... don't worry.

Yogev is being redundant. The West Bank is already the World's Largest Internment Camp just like Gaza is the World's Largest Outdoor Prison.

Early Saturday morning, November 14th, four homes belonging to Palestinians accused in the killings of two illegal settlers were demolished. Three of the houses were located in the Nablus area belonging to the families of imprisoned Samir Zahir Kusa, Kerem Lufti Razek and Yahia Haj Hamed.

The house demolitions are a part of a series of punitive measures by the Israeli government with the declared rationale being “prevention” of future attacks. The unlawful collective punishment, however, is breaking international law by meting out vengeance on the entire family, regardless of the fact that they haven’t been found guilty of any crime.

source

originally posted by: voyger2
a reply to: yuppa
try not make this a circus... The Universal Declaration of Human Rights aplies to all humans of this planet. But for the zionist bashers, such as defense minister and others, like you, palestinians are "beasts".. again karma it will kick you in the back... don't worry.

I t only applies to those who have signed onto it though. thats all im saying.

originally posted by: yuppa

originally posted by: voyger2
a reply to: yuppa
try not make this a circus... The Universal Declaration of Human Rights aplies to all humans of this planet. But for the zionist bashers, such as defense minister and others, like you, palestinians are "beasts".. again karma it will kick you in the back... don't worry.

I t only applies to those who have signed onto it though. thats all im saying.

But Israel is a signatory to the 4th Geneva Convention (1949).

a reply to: dashen

The joint list represents 13 MKs out of 120.
What are the proportions of voting loons in Israeli society so that so many loons ends up in the Knesset ? If you sum up the moderated parties Joint list and Meretz that's 18 MKs out of 120 thus less than 1/6 th of the Israeli population. You get the politicians you deserved as of the elections ...

a reply to: voyger2

The problem with the «fairly logical and pragmatic approach» is the law. There are multiple laws and moral issues that would be violated (but who cares..right?).

No one can be blamed or punished by actions perpetrated by another.

And, more ever, by:
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights

Article 5.
No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.

Article 9.
«No one shall be subjected to arbitrary arrest, detention or exile.»

The above law has created after ww2 to prevent other "kinds of holocausts" / genocides!

This is ridiculous... You are blaming Israel of human rights violation while completely ignoring the fact that Palestinians violating every section in the same declaration .
Cheap propaganda....

a reply to: MaxMech

Do the Palestinians have a state ?

a reply to: theultimatebelgianjoke

Yes, sort of - en.wikipedia.org...