It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: JimOberg
All these factors are absent when judging unknown lights against a dark sky.
So any estimation of the range to the object[s] will be based on guesses and assumptions.
Don't you agree?
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
originally posted by: ZetaRediculian
I am all for speculating and drawing from other cases and all that....but just show where there is one documented case of planes in formation causing people to see things in the details described. Or is there another phenomenon here? like an inordinate amount of burned out hippies living in AZ?
right but if you could say the name I could google it and see if they are a legit company or kooks.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
It was a small electronic subcontractor that made circuit board subassemblies for me. It's just a personal anecdote, not top secret Lockheed Martin whistleblower testimony.
originally posted by: HorusChrist
right but if you could say the name I could google it and see if they are a legit company or kooks.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
It was a small electronic subcontractor that made circuit board subassemblies for me. It's just a personal anecdote, not top secret Lockheed Martin whistleblower testimony.
originally posted by: JimOberg
I had interpreted the comment to mean that human binocular vision showed that the lights in question were close.
The range for accurate depth perception via that method is between 40-60 feet in all the sources I've seen, and with a wider separation [moving head around] maybe a few hundred feet at most.
People judge greater distances while driving cars by estimation based on KNOWN SIZE of more distant objects.
All these factors are absent when judging unknown lights against a dark sky.
So any estimation of the range to the object[s] will be based on guesses and assumptions.
Don't you agree?
originally posted by: TeaAndStrumpets......but simplicity is its advantage, and is exactly why you're most likely to find it only in a controlled, laboratory environment.
I understand that but you might also not want to say the name of the company cuz you made it up.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
right but if you could say the name I could google it and see if they are a legit company or kooks.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
It was a small electronic subcontractor that made circuit board subassemblies for me. It's just a personal anecdote, not top secret Lockheed Martin whistleblower testimony.
I could.
But seeing as I don't know you're not a kook who would harass them with calls... well, you get the picture.
Your registration date and post history would indicate that would be unwise. How about I give it to someone here I trust and they can tell you whether it's a place?
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I understand that but you might also not want to say the name of the company cuz you made it up.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
right but if you could say the name I could google it and see if they are a legit company or kooks.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
It was a small electronic subcontractor that made circuit board subassemblies for me. It's just a personal anecdote, not top secret Lockheed Martin whistleblower testimony.
I could.
But seeing as I don't know you're not a kook who would harass them with calls... well, you get the picture.
Your registration date and post history would indicate that would be unwise. How about I give it to someone here I trust and they can tell you whether it's a place?
who is the third party?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I understand that but you might also not want to say the name of the company cuz you made it up.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
right but if you could say the name I could google it and see if they are a legit company or kooks.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
It was a small electronic subcontractor that made circuit board subassemblies for me. It's just a personal anecdote, not top secret Lockheed Martin whistleblower testimony.
I could.
But seeing as I don't know you're not a kook who would harass them with calls... well, you get the picture.
Your registration date and post history would indicate that would be unwise. How about I give it to someone here I trust and they can tell you whether it's a place?
I offered to tell a third party. That would solve both our issues.
originally posted by: HorusChrist
who is the third party?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I understand that but you might also not want to say the name of the company cuz you made it up.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
right but if you could say the name I could google it and see if they are a legit company or kooks.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
It was a small electronic subcontractor that made circuit board subassemblies for me. It's just a personal anecdote, not top secret Lockheed Martin whistleblower testimony.
I could.
But seeing as I don't know you're not a kook who would harass them with calls... well, you get the picture.
Your registration date and post history would indicate that would be unwise. How about I give it to someone here I trust and they can tell you whether it's a place?
I offered to tell a third party. That would solve both our issues.
originally posted by: TeaAndStrumpets
What we have with the "Phoenix Lights" were sightings that started around sunset, continued on up through astronomical twilight, and then well into the night. Even after twilight -- heck, all night really --
And most if not all witnesses from that one area said the craft, with its distinct "carpenter's square" edges, was only a few hundred feet above them.
True. There is no doubt that people can see illusory contours and get caught up in all manner of UFO disease. No argument here.
I can't show a documented case of planes causing people to describe a massive low flying object - unless Phoenix counts - however the interweb is strewn with supposedly structured flying craft that have turned out to be planes, skydivers, satellites, fireballs, starts, clouds, lanterns, car headlights and even boats.
It is well documented how open memory is to being suggestive and how individuals can get caught up in group themes.
Maybe atmospheric conditions contributed, the flares added further confusion as did media coverage or it was other reasons but the earlier reports were all consistent and didn't mention this huge craft with surface detail
originally posted by: chunder
Go back and take another look at the witness testimony - try the NUFORC site for that night and particularly the reports submitted within a reasonable timeframe.
You will find that a high majority of reports are very consistent with a formation of planes. Jet engines were heard in one instance and planes were identified ny telescope and binocular on at least 3 occasions....
Forget it I am not trying to say you're a liar or anything and even in the end it wouldn't prove anything 100%. I'm just looking for evidence of this v shaped craf and with UFOs it always seems like there is someone saying they saw something but no one with proof.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
who is the third party?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I understand that but you might also not want to say the name of the company cuz you made it up.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
right but if you could say the name I could google it and see if they are a legit company or kooks.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that could just mean the head of engineering had lost his mind too. I imagine you can't say what that company was?
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
that's another problematic thing, it may be unfair and politically incorrect, but it's so hot in Arizona, people get their mind fried and see things. Just makes them a little less trustworthy. This is no offense to anyone in Arizona. If I get proven wrong because pure proof of that v shaped craft comes out, I'd be glad to admit it.
originally posted by: draknoir2
originally posted by: HorusChrist
I was watching a documentary about the phoenix lights on Netflix. Why do all the witnesses have to have pony tails? It's like with the ancient aliens guy with crazy hair. If you want to be taken seriously, get a hair cut, shave, put on a suit. I have to suspect it is done on purpose tho to discredit ufologists and make them all look liked burnt out hippies.
I think it's an AZ thang.
I started working here the year after the Phoenix lights event. I did a lot of business with a subcontractor in Phoenix. During one phone conversation I mentioned it to the head of engineering there and his response was pretty level-headed and matter of fact. There was no doubt in his mind something weird was going on. This was not something that was reported regularly, or at all on this scale. Whatever the explanation(s) I wouldn't chalk it up to Arizonan wackiness.
It was a small electronic subcontractor that made circuit board subassemblies for me. It's just a personal anecdote, not top secret Lockheed Martin whistleblower testimony.
I could.
But seeing as I don't know you're not a kook who would harass them with calls... well, you get the picture.
Your registration date and post history would indicate that would be unwise. How about I give it to someone here I trust and they can tell you whether it's a place?
I offered to tell a third party. That would solve both our issues.
You want a skeptic, no doubt?
originally posted by: chunder
Apologies for snipping the above, I don't believe I have taken it out of context but you are mistaken in your timeline of sightings. First sightings were approx 7:30 to 8:30... Second sightings were approx 10pm from memory, max 10 minutes. If you have any sources that state otherwise please link.
You are also mistaken in what the witnesses reported - the high majority reported what was consistent with a formation of planes at high altitudes. It does depend what source you use for the witness reports as some sites will obviously cherry pick depending on their disposition....
...but if you take a look at all sources available and run your own sanity checks....
...you should see some patterns develop. One of those patterns is definitely that the more "interesting" reports gain the greatest bandwidth - so you have to ask whether that is another phenomenon at play here, cause and effect.
originally posted by: TeaAndStrumpets
......
Why not give more weight to the witnesses who were closest to the object, the most geographically clustered... the ones who appear to also be the most consistent? It seems to me that a person running proper "sanity checks," as you call them, would do that. I guess reasonable people can disagree though. And, of course, in this instance, accepting what those witnesses said would mean the "aircraft in formation" hypothesis becomes untenable.
To me, it'd be more insane if there weren't probes from other places doing some nosing around down here. Look at what an interesting time it is for our species. So this would be the time to do it, too.