Seymour Hersh: Obama's Entire Account Of bin Laden's Death Is One Big Lie

a reply to: wasaka

"In addition, the bizarre and still relatively unexplained deaths of many SEAL Team 6 members taking place immediately after the alleged Bin Laden Raid should be more cause for suspicion."

Actually,

The guys who were on the helicopter (I am assuming you are referring to Extortion-117) came from another squadron of DEVGRU. None of the operators on that Chopper took part in Neptune Spear.

In a word: Baloney. OBL was alive and this has been verified by MANY independent sources, most of which were strong supporters of his. If you claim you do not know why his body was dumped at sea for the crabs to eat, you are being deliberately obtuse about the matter. We were NOT going to allow that man a shrine ANYWHERE. Funny how the same people used to say that he would NEVER be caught or killed "because his existence justified war without end." Then we killed him. . . so you had to change your story, lol.

originally posted by: OtherSideOfTheCoin

originally posted by: proteus33
a reply to: gazzerman
you believe that aman with advanced kidney disease lasred all those years until seals came and took him out?
i believe that turd died in afganistan or pakistan probably in 2002 or 2003.thats why there has never been a real follow up attack since 911. trust me this great usa is not that well protected. i men we can't even stop all the illegal aliens crossing from mexico .

sigh....

I cannot honestly believe some of the stuff that people will believe when it comes to this topic.

Right?! And their "theories" (which are really nothing but "AMERICA SUCKS!!!" over and over) keep changing every time reality gets in their way. . .

originally posted by: jaffo

originally posted by: OtherSideOfTheCoin

originally posted by: proteus33
a reply to: gazzerman
you believe that aman with advanced kidney disease lasred all those years until seals came and took him out?
i believe that turd died in afganistan or pakistan probably in 2002 or 2003.thats why there has never been a real follow up attack since 911. trust me this great usa is not that well protected. i men we can't even stop all the illegal aliens crossing from mexico .

sigh....

I cannot honestly believe some of the stuff that people will believe when it comes to this topic.

Right?! And their "theories" (which are really nothing but "AMERICA SUCKS!!!" over and over) keep changing every time reality gets in their way. . .

I dont think truthers are "anti-American" many of them are very patriotic.

I actually mostly blame the both the alternative and mainstream media for some of the rubbish they write on this topic.

This is an old post from when the incursion into Pakistan to "get bin Laden" took place. A little bit of humor . . .

originally posted by: ipsedixit
In the hacienda of the man who said, "Bring me the head of Alfredo Garcia.", . . . somewhere in Mexico.

Warren Oates, a big phoney smile on his face, his eyes hidden behind his dark shades says, "I don't have the head but I've got something much better."

Evil Mexican ranchero, scowling, "Whaaat? You don't have heeez head? I ordered heeez head you stupid greeengo!"

Oates grimaces. "I buried the body at sea, but I've got something much better that . . . "

Ranchero, "Whaaaaat!!! You bury the body at seeee?!?!?!?! I keeel you now!!!"

He reaches for the gun in his top drawer, while his henchmen grab Oates.

Oates, " Wait senor, wait!"

Ranchero, waving pistol, "Whaaaat is eeet, you stupid cabron?"

Oates, grinning crazily, "I have something much better, senor. I have DNA samples and pictures that my hooker girlfriend took with her own little hands."

Ranchero, looking puzzled. "DNA?! What is DNA? I don't need no DNA, Ohtts, you stupid imbecil.

He riddles Oates with bullets, screaming, "I don't need no DNA. I waaaant theee head!!!!!"

I'd like to hear what Al CIAda has to say about all this. If they are a genuine terrorist organization, now is the perfect opportunity to release the news that bin Laden was killed years ago, but that the death was kept secret for operational reasons.

Of course if they are a fake organization, they will go with the State Department on this "incident".

a reply to: schuyler

He has cited multiple sources within the article.

a reply to: c0gN1t1v3D1ss0nanC3

Its just as believable as the official story. Oh the CIA just happened to find Osama Bin Laden hiding less then 10 miles from the largest Pakistani military base. They went in and killed an unarmed man, the one man that supposedly the 'master mind' behind so many attacks and so many future attacks. The man with all that knowledge they just killed him. Oh and after that they respected him so much that they had to give him a burial at sea. Oh and then half of the navy seals, and almost all that published something about the raids, oh right they are now dead. Seems to me that we dont know either way, so try to keep an open mind.

a reply to: WonOunce

Oh and then half of the navy seals, and almost all that published something about the raids, oh right they are now dead

You are not the only one who believes this on ATS.

But honestly every time i hear it i want to scream!!!

The members of DEVGRU who took part in Neptune Spear were not on Extortion-117

originally posted by: jaffo
In a word: Baloney. OBL was alive and this has been verified by MANY independent sources, most of which were strong supporters of his. If you claim you do not know why his body was dumped at sea for the crabs to eat, you are being deliberately obtuse about the matter. We were NOT going to allow that man a shrine ANYWHERE. Funny how the same people used to say that he would NEVER be caught or killed "because his existence justified war without end." Then we killed him. . . so you had to change your story, lol.

Who is being deliberately obtuse about this matter?

If everything you say is true, then you are still being
deliberately obtuse to dismiss the alternative out of
hand. The question is when and where did UBL die.

You are right. We were NOT going to allow that man
a shire ANYWHERE. Nor were we going to tell the
true about how he died. We wrote the history
so that it would serve the victor, namely U.S.

That's the way all of history is written. Those who
deny this are being deliberately obtuse.

a reply to: OtherSideOfTheCoin

Oh, okay thanks, because their facial expressions made it
look like they were watching people being killed very
graphically.

Rebel 5

www.bbc.co.uk...

originally posted by: combatmaster
www.bbc.co.uk...

Couldn't care less. He's dead and I'm happy about that. I love the fact that he was shot right in the face, that he never got to spew his garbage rhetoric to his fanatic followers. He died like a rat, living in a filthy house, watching porn (my what a holy guy, right?!), and eating whatever could be smuggled to him. Maybe they were hiding him, maybe they weren't. Either way, he's dead. So yeah, it took years, but we got him. Oh yeah, we got him.

originally posted by: kazryll
a reply to: gazzerman

Personally I always thought Benazir Bhutto's claim that Osama bin Laden's was disposed of years before the U.S. claimed they did it interesting - and unfortunate she was then assassinated.

Yep that's the version I go by..... and also lean a little towards Osama dieing from health issues.... The SEAL Team Six story is an elaborately staged BS Hoax created by the US gov.....

originally posted by: imitator

originally posted by: kazryll
a reply to: gazzerman

Personally I always thought Benazir Bhutto's claim that Osama bin Laden's was disposed of years before the U.S. claimed they did it interesting - and unfortunate she was then assassinated.

Yep that's the version I go by..... and also lean a little towards Osama dieing from health issues.... The SEAL Team Six story is an elaborately staged BS Hoax created by the US gov.....

Riiiiight. We flew into another Country under cover of darkness, lost a chopper, utilized our best special forces, and risked an international incident just to pretend we killed the guy who was already dead. Because, logic. Yeah, that makes perfect sense. It's not like pretty much ANYONE who already knew the guy was dead (if what you are saying is true) would have the ability to pretty much instantly knock that one right out of the park. Yeesh. . .

originally posted by: OtherSideOfTheCoin
a reply to: kazryll

Really.....

Then read THIS

Yes, Bhutto did misspeak and there is no credible evidence to suggest Osama was killed by Sheikh.

However, there is some incredible weight to the theory that Osama died of kidney failure in 2001 while at a Pakistani hospital. I could create an entire thread on this subject, but I doubt it would garner the interest the topic would deserve.

Nevertheless, the official story is complete tripe.

originally posted by: Boeing777
You've got to be a class A retard to actually believe the official story that bin Laden got buried at sea.

This is what The Sun came up with the following morning.

That's how we roll in Britain - BinBagged.

Pure class.

originally posted by: jaffo
Riiiiight. We flew into another Country under cover of darkness, lost a chopper, utilized our best special forces, and risked an international incident just to pretend we killed the guy who was already dead. Because, logic.

What I do know is Bin Laden died in late 2001.... other government experts from around the world have confirmed that claim at the time.... I don't know how old you are, if you was keeping up with news back in the day, you would have known that OBL had died.......

We fly into other countries all the freaking time breaking international laws! Those idiots in the white house cant keep a straight face when they lie.... they just capitalized on a down helicopter and claimed a BS story on Bin Laden to push more BS terror laws....