It looks like you're using an Ad Blocker.
Please white-list or disable AboveTopSecret.com in your ad-blocking tool.
Thank you.
Some features of ATS will be disabled while you continue to use an ad-blocker.
originally posted by: CharlieSpeirs
originally posted by: Kapusta
I would like to Add that I am Salafi and I am on par with most of what OP shared .
But I also wanted to make note that these Khuaraij make claims of being salafi but they are not .
Real quick Bio , Born raised Christian , studied religion , found Islam , studied Islam for years , became salafi , Because its based off of FACT and Evidence of scripture and not bid'ah ( innovation of scripture ) . One can say it's the purest form of Islam .
You see the salafi trace everything back to the Shahaba and Muhammad (pbuh) we follow Islam how they followed . If it's not able to be traced back then it's questionable (in rearguard to hadith etc ) because over the years like many other religions Islam has become Infected with Innovation of scripture and culture tradition . so as a salaf we want to practice the purest form of Islam .
one can compare it to Orthodox Christianity vs west burrow . of course salafi being orthodoxy lol .
So long story short ! True Islam does not have all these extremes you see on MSM and the internet . Much of that comes from Innovation and culture tradition and influence .
anyway hope this helps !
P.S Op I still go fishing , hangout with friends , live life ! do fun things ! you name it i do it ! being salafi means siticking to the Quran and Sunna !
Salam alikume Akhi thanks for the post
Nice post Kapusta, Salam.
& now that this has been stated, there is one more you missed OP...
Myself, I am a Quranist.
& do not follow Hadith...
Quite a minority, but I could back it up with scripture when I have the time to edit this post why I chose to be a Quranist.
originally posted by: MarioOnTheFly
a reply to: CharlieSpeirs
So is there a written source, preferably muslim, that defines what consitutes this true Jihad...what you wrote...somehow seems to me like your own understanding of the term...and perhaps some of it is wishful thinking.
Back in school...we were told a simple definition...something like...holy war against the infidels. So...can you please point me to scolarly definition from a valid muslim source....i would appreciate it.
originally posted by: JourneymanWelder
i didnt click here for a islam history lesson! clicked to find out why wahabis and their backers are responsible!
originally posted by: MarioOnTheFly
a reply to: CharlieSpeirs
going through your link...
in the mean time...
An infidel is someone who persecutes Muslims or fights against Islam (tries to quash it) & tries to stop Muslims believing what we do...
So in that sense it's a Holy War against infidels...
a definition of a word infidel:
noun
1.
Religion.
a person who does not accept a particular faith, especially Christianity.
(in Christian use) an unbeliever, especially a Muslim.
(in Muslim use) a person who does not accept the Islamic faith; kaffir.
2.
a person who has no religious faith; unbeliever.
3.
(loosely) a person who disbelieves or doubts a particular theory, belief, creed, etc.; skeptic.
Your definition of a word infidel is a bit different than what the dictionary says. You assign a much more heavier meaning to it...than the word itself means.
According to the dictionary...it is simply a person that does not believe or accept certain religion. Nowhere does it state:
An infidel is someone who persecutes Muslims
...not believing and persecuting believers is not the same. To me this appears, since it's all about interpretation and context, that you want that word to be more than it is...simply to validate the concept of Jihad as...somewhat benign and defensive....while if we go strictly by the definition of the word infidel...in language we are both using...Jihad would than be... war on non believers in Islam.
I am...by definition...an infidel...a non believer...whether from Christian or from Islamic point of view (I reject both).
I bring this up because I've had this conversation with many different types of believers. Take prayer for instance, like you mentioned. What's the "correct" way to pray? As in, what form of prayer does God accept? Each school of thought has variations on how to pray, so which is correct? And if there are so many variations, how can we be 100% sure if any of the versions taught today is the "correct" one? Either only one version is correct & the rest are wrong;
originally posted by: Kapusta
a reply to: enlightenedservant
Well since you would like to answer for him then maybe you can answer my question
Is the whole deen covered in the Quran ?
Prophet Muhammad understood the Quran more then anyone and he prayed five times a day and gave instruction on how to do it ( Hadith) ,
This is prime example of Bid'ah .
You take your personal feeling about Islam (witch at this point I have to assume your knowledge of Islam is weak ) and Add an idea of how it's suppose to be .
This is exactly what extremist do ! they take Ideas ! about Islam and twist them to fit their own belief system, while rejecting 1000's of years of Scholarship and FACT.
Say ! some ayat in the Quran require Hadith to fully understand how do you purpose to understand it when yo reject Hadith ?
sects are formed by doing exactly what your doing . Innovation !
I bring this up because I've had this conversation with many different types of believers. Take prayer for instance, like you mentioned. What's the "correct" way to pray? As in, what form of prayer does God accept? Each school of thought has variations on how to pray, so which is correct? And if there are so many variations, how can we be 100% sure if any of the versions taught today is the "correct" one? Either only one version is correct & the rest are wrong;
Hmmm well ! if you understood Hadith and how it's classed and traced back to prophet Muhammad through chain's of narration then you would know that to witch was correct !
but you choose to reject it .
this was just a quick youtube search ...
maybe his way of explaining it will help you to understand more of why its important to follow the Quran and sunna
One correction about the brother in the video . Hadith was also written down and not just passed down verbally.
Do you think that the Qur'an alone is not enough to get into Heaven? As in, do you think God's direct teachings aren't enough? The Qur'an itself says it is complete. So as long as he's following it, why is there a problem?
originally posted by: CharlieSpeirs
a reply to: MarioOnTheFly
You wouldn't really be defined by he Quran to be honest.
It's always about unbelievers who fight against Islam (physically) or persecute Muslims because of what we believe.
Criticism of Islam is not a transgression...
Not in the Quran anyhow.
We would be told to debate with you on the finer points.
If you become judgmental or spread lies then we are told to leave the room, change the subject, or debate properly...
Even apostates...
Praphrasing the Quran says "if someone believes, then disbelieves, then believes again, and goes on in disbelief, Allah will surely not guide them"
But it doesn't say to harm them in any way.
Judgement is for Allah...
Look at my signature...
It's basically telling Muhammad (PBUH) that he is not important enough to force his beliefs on others, because if Allah (SWT) willed for everyone to believe they would, & what is free will without choice?
So it's not hard to interpret when you read the full scripture in context.